F19B/0291: The demolition of the existing single storey extension at the side, the construction of a new porch and a bay window extension to the front, a new two storey extension to the rear and side, the raising of the roof ridge line by extension of the existing front roof slope, the conversion of the attic space including two dormer windows and a velux roof-light to the front, and an increase in height of the existing chimney stack.
Palmerstown, Oldtown, Co. Dublin, A45 P448.
DecisionRefuse permission
Decided10 January 2020
Application typePermission
Source documents3
Site
What is on file
3refusal reasons0conditions8nearby records
Decision details
Core application dates and identifiers from the public planning record.Planning analysis
Refusal reasons and planning conditions extracted from the public decision file.Refusal reasons
Visual Amenity
Unsympathetic design and excessive scale negatively impact the character of the existing dwelling, the rural landscape, and visual amenities.
Objective PM46, Fingal Development Plan 2017-2023unsympathetic design and excessive scale negatively impacts on the character of the existing single storey dwelling and on the visual amenities of the receiving landscape
Design
Specific design elements including split-level roof, inconsistent window proportions, large dormers, poor roof-to-wall ratio, and non-integrated chimney are incongruous with the rural area.
Objective PM46, Fingal Development Plan 2017-2023considered incongruous with the character of the rural area
Wastewater Percolation
Insufficient information provided to demonstrate adequate foul and surface water disposal arrangements.
EPA Code of Practice for Wastewater Treatment and Disposal Systems Serving Single Dwellings (2009); GDSDS Regional Drainage Policiesnot satisfied... that adequate arrangements are in place for the disposal of foul and surface water
Conditions
No conditions
No conditions are on record for this application yet.
Planning a project near Palmerstown, Oldtown, Co. Dublin, A45 P448.?
Get the precedent report for this site: every grant and refusal within 5 km, and the planners' reasons. €49 incl. VAT, PDF by email.Source documents
Original council portal records and source PDFs where available.- Application fileApplication file on planning.agileapplications.ieSource portal
- Notification Of DecisionSource: planningapi.agileapplications.ie / BADD1DD633BE11EA99D33464A927EB6F.tif / Document 683747Source PDF
- Chief Executives OrderSource: planningapi.agileapplications.ie / BADD1DD933BE11EA99D33464A927EB6F.tif / Document 683748Source PDF
Nearby precedent
Similar nearby applications linked to this planning decision.- F23A/0197Demolition of an existing single storey side extension to dwelling and store, the increase in ridge and eaves height of existing roof, construction of a new 1 1/2 storey rear extension, change in fenestration to existing front elevation to include new material finish of stone, construction of new garage, new waste water treatment system and all associated site works. / 0.0 km away / 19 June 2023Refused
- F22A/0519Demolition of an existing single storey side extension to dwelling and store, the increase in ridge and eaves height of existing roof, construction of a new two storey rear extension, change in fenestration to existing front elevation to include new material finish of stone, construction of new garage, new waste water treatment system and all associated site works. / 0.0 km away / 21 November 2022Refused
- F23A/0077Outline planning permission will consist of converting existing garage/workshop and adding extension to provide a new 3No. bed detached bungalow. The existing vehicular entrance will still be used for new & existing house. Demolishing of existing shed & removal of steel containers and all ancillary works. / 0.6 km away / 24 April 2023Refused
- F22A/0295The development will consist of the following: 1 The construction of a new detatched two-storey dwelling. 2. New entrance to site & associated site works to existing front boundary. 3. New proprietary wastewater treatment system & polishing filter. 4. All associated site works. / 0.8 km away / 29 July 2022Refused
- F22A/0349A proposed one and a half storey extension to side of existing cottage, new replacement on-site wastewater treatment plant, revisions to existing front vehicular entrance and all associated site development works. / 0.9 km away / 31 August 2022Refused
- F20A/0486Proposed two storey extension to side of existing cottage, new detached storey and a half garage, new replacement onsite wastewater treatment plant, revisions to existing front vehicular entrance and all associated site development works. / 0.9 km away / 23 November 2020Refused
- F08A/0173/E1Development will consist of (A) the rehabilitation, alteration and ext / 1.0 km away / 30 August 2013Refused
- F20A/0572The retention application consists of an extension to truck and agricultural tractors yard previously granted planning permission Ref. No. P3680/84 to include offices, fuelling station petrol interceptors, O'Reilly Oakstown treatment system and percolation area and parking area including all associated site works. / 1.1 km away / 13 January 2021Refused