06S.245500Submitted 17 September 2015 / decided 18 January 2016
Appeal decidedRefuse Permission
- Appeal submittedAppeal reference 06S.24550017 September 2015
- Appeal decisionRefuse Permission18 January 2016
St. Endas, Sarah Curran Avenue, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16.
Planning application SD15B/0249
DecisionRefuse permission
Decided09 September 2015
Application typePermission
Source documents1
Site
What is on file
0refusal reasons0conditions8nearby records
Proposed development
Application description published by South Dublin County Council.Application and appeal history
Structured appeal stages, outcomes and source documents currently tied to this application.Decision details
Core application dates and identifiers from the public planning record.Planning analysis
Refusal reasons and planning conditions extracted from the public decision file.Refusal reasons
Refusal reasons not machine-readable
Documents are indexed. Reason extraction for South Dublin has not started yet.
Conditions
No conditions
No conditions are on record for this application yet.
Planning a project near St. Endas, Sarah Curran Avenue, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16.?
Get a site risk brief with the local decision pattern and up to 80 detailed nearby comparables (40 refusals and 40 grants), including extracted reasons and source links. €39 incl. VAT, PDF by email.Searching the records is free. A one-off brief for this site is €39, and Pro at €19/month adds full document access and the planning AI for people tracking more than one site.Source documents
Original council portal records and source PDFs where available.Included in site brief
1 council document — in the €39 site risk brief
Site brief
Nearby precedent
Similar nearby applications linked to this planning decision.- S99A/0581Demolition of existing house and construction of 2 no. 4 bedroom dormer bungalows, one with attached double domestic garage. / 0.0 km away / 18 October 1999Refused
- SD17B/0393New pedestrian gated entrance (0.9m wide) and new vehicular gated entrance (3.5m wide) adjacent to existing vehicular entrance with access onto Sarah Curran Avenue. / 0.0 km away / 24 April 2018Refused
- SD13A/0135Retention permission for existing single storey dwelling, attached shed and existing entrance as constructed; permission to subdivide the site of Planning Permission Reg. Ref. S99A/0886. / 0.0 km away / 28 August 2013Refused
- SD14A/0152Retention permission for an existing bungalow with attached shed; planning permission sought for alterations to the front and rear elevations of the existing bungalow to be retained, including a new front porch; planning permission sought for a new vehicular entrance with improved sightlines and for the existing vehicular entrance to be blocked up and permission sought for the subdivision of the site to facilitate the two existing dwellings with the new shared vehicular entrance. / 0.0 km away / 04 September 2014Refused
- S00B/0468Retain revised access and shoulder walls, gate piers etc. / 0.1 km away / 07 September 2000Refused
- SD09A/0399Redevelopment of the site known as Silveracre House, off Sarah Curran Avenue, which is a Protected Structure. The development will consist of the following: (1) Demolition of single storey additions to the side of existing Silveracre House and the complete refurbishment and division of same to provide 2 new houses, House 01 being a 307sq.m. 4-bedroom dwelling accessed from existing main entrance on eastern elevation to Silveracre House with its own new private rear garden, and House 02 to be contained in the existing return to the main dwelling to be refurbished to a 193sq.m. 3-bedroom dwelling to be accessed from existing entrance on western elevation with its own new private rear garden; (2) Construction of a new gate lodge at the entrance comprising of a 2-bedroom unit and a new ESB sub-station for the entire site; (3) Demolition of existing storage sheds & structures to the north-west of the site and construction of 1 block of apartments in its place providing for 20 no. 2-bedroom apartments, and 8 no. 1-bedroom apartments all with individual balconies and terraces in a 4-storey over basement building giving a total number of 28 apartments, 2 houses and 1 Gate Lodge, giving a total of 31 units in the entire development; (4) The construction of a 1978sq.m. basement to provide 48 car parking spaces in total; (5) Boundary wall and entrance to remain as existing, with provision for a new pedestrian entrance and gate to either side of vehicular entrance. This development has been designed to allow for the retention of certain key specimen trees of exceptional quality and the removal of other trees on the site of lesser importance, as per tree specialist recommendations, along with hard and soft landscaping including Bicycle Stores, Bin Stores, and the introduction of extensive new mature planting including all associated site works (all within a site area of 8218sq.m; (6) The following traffic calming measures are proposed; (a) a traffic calming island is to be installed at the existing entrance onto Sarah Curran Avenue, reducing the overall width of Sarah Curran Avenue to 3.5m locally - this traffic calming island will extend for 30-40m approx either side & will include the relevant signage, protective bollards, ramps etc; (b) a 1200mm wide footpath is to be provided at the bridge to the south west of the proposed site on Sarah Curran Avenue, which will reduce the width of Sarah Curran Avenue to 3m locally at this point - this footpath is to be 10m approx in length and is to be protected against vehicles by the installation of minimum 3 no. bollards; (c) vehicular & pedestrian traffic lights are to be installed at the junction of Sarah Curran Avenue and Whitechurch Avenue. / 0.1 km away / 26 February 2010Refused
- SD07A/0522Redevelopment of a Protected Structure: (1) demolition of single storey additions to the side of existing Silveracre House and the complete refurbishment of same to provide 2 new dwellings: dwelling 01 being a 357sqm, 4-bedroom dwelling accessed from existing main entrance on eastern elevation to Silveracre House with its own new private rear garden, a new 50sqm basement extension area providing additional storage/utility area and accessing the new basement area, and dwelling 02 to be contained in the existing return to the main dwelling to be refurbished to a 193sqm, 3-bedroom dwelling to be accessed from existing entrance on western elevation, with its own new private rear garden, with a new stairs to access the new basement area; (2) demolition of existing storage sheds & structures to the north-west of the site and the construction of Block A: a 3-storey over basement block of 6 no. 4-bedroom, 245sqm terraced dwellings with roof terrace, individual rear gardens and own door access all to the immediate west of Silveracre House with level access from the basement level; (3) construction of Block B: a 3-storey over basement block of 6 no. 4-bedroom, 245sqm terraced dwellings with roof terrace, individual rear gardens and own door access, all to the immediate north of Silveracre House with level access from the basement level; (4) construction of Block C: a 3-storey over basement block of 6 no. 4-bedroom, 245sqm terraced dwellings with roof terrace, individual rear gardens and own door access, all to the immediate east of Silveracre House with level access from the basement level; (5) construction of Block D: a 3-storey block of 3 no. 4-bedroom, 212sqm terraced dwellings with roof terrace, individual rear gardens and own door access, all to the south-east of Silveracre House; (6) construction of Block E: a 3-storey block of 3 no. 4-bedroom, 212sqm terraced dwellings with roof terrace, individual rear gardens and own door access, all to the south of Silveracre House, giving a total number of 26 dwellings in the entire development. Access level of Blocks A, B & C to be constructed as a complete basement to provide 40 parking spaces in total, along with 18 no. bicycle parking, bin storage, and relevant plant area. 12 no. car-parking spaces are to be provided within the landscaped area on the ground level as parking for Block D & E. Planning permission is also sought for the demolition of existing entrance gates and boundary wall onto Sarah Curran Avenue and the realignment of the boundary wall to provide new footpath onto Sarah Curran Avenue and the relocation of the existing entrance to provide a new vehicular & pedestrian entrance for the development onto Sarah Curran Avenue and the construction of a new stone boundary wall to match the character of existing boundary wall. Planning permission is sought for the provision of an ESB substation to serve the development. This development has been designed to allow for the retention of certain key specimen trees of exceptional quality and the removal of other trees on the site of less importance, as per tree specialist recommendations, along with a complete hard and soft landscaping and the introduction of extensive new mature planting, including all associated site works. / 0.1 km away / 27 August 2007Refused
- SD14A/0228Amendments to previously granted SD13A/0071 comprising of construction of four semi detached dwellings in lieu of two detached previously granted with private open space to the southern boundary of the site associated with Reg. Ref. SD10A/0345 and SD13A/0071 with revised internal road layout, landscaping and associated site works and services. / 0.1 km away / 17 December 2014Refused