Planning precedent report

We, Kinwest Ltd., intend to apply for planning permission for development on lands at Auburn House (Protected Structure) and Little Auburn off the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road, Malahide, Co. Dublin. The lands are generally bound by the R107 road to the east, ‘Beech Lodge’, ‘Bellmont’, ‘The Lodge’, ‘Bellview’, and ‘Elgin’ to the south, and Abington to the northeast and west. The proposed development will consist of amendments to the previously permitted development at the subject site, granted under Reg. Ref. F24A/0812E (which previously amended Reg. Ref. F22A/0580 / ABP Ref. 316498-23). The proposed amendments relate solely to 6 no. house plots, Nos. 19, 20, 21, 28, 29, and 30. The proposed amendments consist of the following: (a) Change of house type at Plot 20 from the previously approved House Type nCa, mid-terrace 2-storey, 3-bedroom house, to now provide House Type nC5 mid-terrace, 2-storey, 4-bedroom house with associated amendments to the rear gardens of Plot 19 and Plot 21 to accommodate this change of house type. (b) Change of house type at Plot 29 from the previously approved House Type nCb, mid-terrace 2-storey, 3-bedroom house, to now provide House Type nC3, mid-terrace, 2-storey, 4-bedroom house, with associated amendments to the rear gardens of Plot 28 and Plot 30 to accommodate this change of house type. (c) And all other ancillary site development works that are necessary to accommodate these proposed amendments.

The proposed development will consist of amendments to the previously approved development at the subject site, as granted under Reg. Ref. F22A/0580 (ABP Ref. 316498-23). The proposed changes will see a reduction in the number of units from 52 no. units to 33 no. units and the provision of a new creche facility as follows: The omission of the previously approved 4-storey Apartment Block 4 (comprising of 4 no. 1-bedroom units and 13 no. 2-bedroom units, along with integrated creche on the ground floor as per condition 2(c)(i) attached to the Board Order ABP Ref. 316498-23, 4-storey Apartment Block 5 (comprising of 8 no. 1-bedroom units and 10 no. 2-bedroom units), 3-storey Duplex Block 1 (comprising of 4 no. 1-bedroom units, 2 no. 2-bedroom units, and 2 no. 3-bedroom units), House plots 13-21 comprising House Type C (3-bedroom 2-storey, mid terraced unit), House Type C3 (4-bedroom, 2-storey, mid terraced unit), House Type E1 (4-bedroom 2-storey, end of terraced unit) and House Type F1 (4-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced unit); all of which are to be replaced with the following: A detached, 2-storey creche with associated car parking, outdoor play area and external escape stairs; A 3-storey Duplex Block 1 with balconies (13 no. units comprising 5 no. 1-bedroom units and 8 no. 3-bedroom units), 20 no. houses at plots 13-32, consisting of House Type nC2 (4-bedroom, 2-storey, semi-detached and end of terrace unit units), House Type nCa (3-bedroom 2-storey, mid terraced unit) House Type nCb (3-bedroom, 2-storey, mid-terraced unit), House Type nE1 (4-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced unit) House Type nF3a (4-bedroom, 2-storey, semi-detached unit), House Type nG (4-bedroom, 2-storey, mid-terraced unit) House Type nG1 (4-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced unit), House Type nG2 (4-bedroom, 2-storey, detached unit) and House Type nG3 (4-bed, 2-storey end of terraced unit). The proposed development will also comprise of surface car parking; 1 no. ESB substation; 1 no. single storey bicycle store; boundary treatment; landscaping works, including associated reductions in the gardens of plots 13-21; and all other ancillary site development works that are necessary to accommodate these proposed amendments.

The proposed development will consist of amendments to the previously permitted development at the subject site, granted under Reg. Ref. F22A/0580 (ABP Ref. 316498-23). The proposed amendments relate solely to a total of 28 of the previously permitted houses (comprising 1 no. 3-bedroom unit and 27 no. 4-bedroom units) to be replaced by 28 no. houses (comprising 1 no. 2-bedroom unit and 27 no. 4-bedroom units). These changes shall consist of the following: Previously approved plots 1-12, comprising House Type E (4 bedroom 2 storey mid-terrace unit), House Type E1 (4 bedroom 2 storey end of terrace unit), House Type E2 (4 bedroom 2 storey end of terrace unit), and House Type F (4 bedroom 2 storey end of terrace unit), located at the south-easternmost side of Little Auburn (a total of 12 no. houses) to be replaced with House Type nE (4 bedroom, 2 storey mid-terrace unit), House Type nE1 (4 bedroom, 2 storey end of terraced unit), House Type nE2 (4 bedroom, 2 storey end of terrace unit), House Type nF3b (4 bedroom, 2 storey end of terrace unit) and House Type nH (2 bedroom, 2 storey mid terrace unit) with associated reductions in these gardens; Previously approved plots 37-52, comprising House Type C (3 bedroom 2 storey mid-terrace unit), House Type C2 (4 bedroom 2 storey end of terrace & semi-detached unit), House Type D (4 bedroom 2 storey semi-detached unit), House Type E (4 bedroom 2 storey mid-terrace unit), House Type E1 (4 bedroom 2 storey end of terrace unit), House Type F (4 bedroom 2 storey end of terrace unit) and House Type F1 (4 bedroom 2 storey semi-detached unit), located at the north-easternmost side of Little Auburn (a total of 16 no. houses) to be replaced with House Type nC2 (4 bedroom, 2 storey end of terrace & semi-detached unit), House Type nC3 (4 bedroom, 2 storey mid-terrace unit), House Type nD (4 bedroom, 2 storey semi-detached unit), House Type nE (4 bedroom, 2 storey mid-terrace unit), House Type nE1 (4 bedroom, 2 storey end of terraced unit), House Type nF3a (4 bedroom, 2 storey semi-detached unit) and House Type nF3b (4 bedroom, 2 storey end of terrace unit). The proposed development will also comprise of in curtilage car parking; boundary treatment; landscaping works; bicycle and bin stores, and all other ancillary site development works that are necessary to accommodate these proposed amendments.

The preservation and protection of the existing Protected Structure of Auburn and its stables as 1 no. residential dwelling; the conversion of the existing stables of Auburn House to provide for storage space for the main Auburn House and the construction of 98 no. residential units (53 no. houses, 37 no. apartments and 8 no. duplex apartments) comprising 53 no. houses (5 no. two storey 2-bedroom houses, 13 no. two storey 3-bedroom houses, 1 no. 1.5 storey (dormer) 3-bedroom house, 33 no. two storey 4 - bedroom houses and 1 no. 2.5 storey (dormer) 4-bedroom house) comprising detached, semi-detached, terraced and courtyard type houses, all with associated car parking, and 1 no. three storey duplex apartment block (Duplex Apartment Block 1) consisting of 8 no. own-door duplex units (4 no. 1-bedroom units, 2 no. 2-bedroom units and 2 no. 3- bedroom units), and 2 no. four storey apartment blocks consisting of 37 no. units comprised of the following: Apartment Block 4 is a 4 storey block (4 no. 1-bedroom units and 15 no. 2-bedroom units), all provided with private balconies/terraces and refuse store, bicycle parking and plant at ground level, Apartment Block 5 is a 4 storey block (4 no. 1-bedroom units and 14 no. 2-bedroom units), all provided with private balconies/terraces and refuse store, bicycle parking and plant at ground level; associated car parking and bicycle parking (with a total of 153 no. car parking spaces). The proposed development shall also provide landscaped public and communal open spaces, public lighting, 1 no. ESB unit substation; 1 no. new foul pumping station; proposed foul sewer works along Back Road and Kinsealy Lane, The demolition of the modern bungalow dwelling known as 'Little Auburn' and associated outbuildings and stables; Closing of the existing vehicular entrance at the R107 Malahide Road serving Little Auburn; and all associated ancillary site development infrastructure including foul and surface water drainage, internal roads, cycle paths and footpaths, and boundary walls and fences. Vehicular access to the proposed development is to be via a new signalised entrance at the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road junction, with the existing entrance to Auburn House from the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road to be maintained as a shared vehicular access to serve Auburn House and 'Bellmont', 'The Lodge', 'Bellview', and 'Elgin'. An Environmental Impact Assessment Report and Natura Impact Statement have been prepared in respect of the proposed development. The Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR) and Natura Impact Statement (NIS) are available for inspection or purchase at a fee not exceeding the reasonable cost of making a copy during office hours at the Planning Authority. Lands at Auburn House (Protected Structure), Little Auburn and Streamstown off the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road and Carey's Lane (accessed via Streamstown Lane), Malahide, Co. Dublin. The lands are generally bound by the R107 road to the east, 'Beech Lodge' to the south, Clairville Lodge to the south (off Carey's Lane), by dwellings known as 'The Coop', 'Halstead' and 'Rockport House' to the south west (off Carey's Lane) and Abington to the west AI Received 03/02/2023

We, Kinwest Ltd., intend to apply for planning permission for development on lands at Auburn House (Protected Structure) and Little Auburn off the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road, Malahide, Co. Dublin. The lands are generally bound by the R107 road to the east, 'Beech Lodge', 'Bellmont', 'The Lodge', 'Bellview', and 'Elgin' to the south, and Abington to the northeast and west. The proposed development seeks to provide amendments to the previously permitted development at the subject site, granted under Reg. Ref. F22A/0581 / ABP Ref. 316504-23 (which was previously amended under Reg. Ref. F24A/1179E). The proposed amendments relate previously permitted plot numbers 03, 04, 05, 09, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, and 28. The proposed amendments consist of the following: (a) Change of House Type at Plot 03 from the previously approved House Type nC6, 4-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced unit to previously approved House Type nC2, 4-bedroom, 2-storey, semi-detached unit. (b) Change of House Type at Plot 04 from the previously approved House Type A2, 3-bedroom, 2-storey, mid terrace unit to House Type nA2, 3-bedroom, 2-storey, semi-detached unit. (c) Change of House Type at Plot 05 from the previously approved House Type nJ1, 2-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced unit to House Type nJ2, 2-bedroom, 2-storey, detached unit. (d) Revised Plot area, private open space, and boundary treatment to Plot 9. (e) Revised Plot area, private open space, and boundary treatment to Plot 10. (f) Revised Plot area, private open space, and boundary treatment to Plot 11. (g) Change of House Type at Plot 12 from the previously approved House Type nCa 3-bedroom, 2-storey, mid-terraced unit to House Type nH1, 2-bedroom, 2-storey, mid terrace unit. (h) Change of House Type at Plot 13 from the previously approved House Type nC5 4-bedroom, 2-storey, mid-terrace unit to previously approved House Type nE1, 4-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced unit. (i) Change of House Type at Plot 14 and Plot 15 from the previously approved House Type nE1, 4-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced units to House Type nC2 4-bedroom, 2-storey, semi-detached units. (j) Change of House Type at Plot 16 from the previously approved House Type nCa 3-bedroom, 2-storey, mid-terraced unit, to previously approved House Type nE1, 4-bedroom, 2-storey, end of terraced unit. (k) Change of House Type at Plot 17 from the previously approved House Type nCa 3-bedroom, 2-storey, mid-terraced unit to House Type nH1, 2-bedroom, 2-storey, mid terrace unit. (l) Revised plot area, private open space, and boundary treatment to Plot 18 (m) Change of House Type at Plot 19 and 28 from the previously approved House Type nD3, 4-bedroom, 2-storey semi-detached units to previously approved nD1 4-bedroom, 2-storey, detached units. (n) And all other ancillary site development works including parking, boundary treatment, landscaping works, and engineering works that are necessary to accommodate these proposed amendments.

The preservation and protection of the existing Protected Structure of Auburn House and its stables as 1 no. residential dwelling; the conversion of the existing stables of Auburn House to provide for storage space for the main Auburn House and the construction of 92 no. residential units (45 no. houses, 34 no. apartments and 13 no. duplex apartments) comprising 45 no. houses (3 no. two storey 2-bedroom houses, 17 no. two storey 3-bedroom houses, and 25 no. two storey 4-bedroom houses) comprising detached, semi-detached, terraced and courtyard type houses, and all with associated car parking; Apartment Block 2 comprising 1 no. four storey block consisting 17 no. units (4 no. 1-bedroom units and 12 no. 2-bedroom units and 1 no. 3-bedroom unit) all provided with private balconies/terraces and refuse store, bicycle parking and plant at ground level; Apartment Block 3 comprising 1 no. four storey block consisting 17 no. units (4 no. 1-bedroom units and 13 no. 2-bedroom units) all provided with private balconies/terraces and refuse store, bicycle parking and plant at ground level; Duplex Apartment Block 2 comprising a 3 storey block consisting of 6 no. units (3 no. 1 bedroom unit and 3 no. 3 bedroom units) with balconies/terraces and associated car parking and bicycle parking; Duplex Apartment Block 3 comprising a 3 storey block consisting of 6 no. units (3 no. 1 bedroom unit, 1 no. 2-bedroom unit and 2 no. 3 bedroom units) with balconies/terraces and associated car parking and bicycle parking; Duplex Apartment Block 4 comprising a 2 storey block consisting of 1 no. 2 bedroom unit above an undercroft car park with a balcony and associated car parking (with a total of 147 no. car parking spaces) and bicycle parking; the proposed development shall also provide landscaped public and communal open spaces, public lighting, 1 no. ESB unit substation; 1 no. new foul pumping station; proposed foul sewer works along Back Road and Kinsealy Lane, the part demolition of a stable block at Little Auburn; closing of the existing vehicular entrance at the R107 Malahide Road serving Little Auburn; and all associated ancillary site development infrastructure including foul and surface water drainage, internal roads, cycle paths and footpaths, and boundary walls and fences. Vehicular access to the proposed development is to be via a new signalised entrance at the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road junction, with the existing entrance to Auburn House from the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road to be maintained as a shared vehicular access to serve Auburn House and 'Bellmont', 'The Lodge', 'Bellview', and 'Elgin'. An Environmental Impact Assessment Report and Natura Impact Statement have been prepared in respect of the proposed development. The Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR) and Natura Impact Statement (NIS) are available for inspection or purchase at a fee not exceeding the reasonable cost of making a copy during office hours at the Planning Authority. Lands at Auburn House (Protected Structure), Little Auburn and Streamstown off the R107 Malahide Road/Dublin Road and Carey's Lane (accessed via Streamstown Lane), Malahide, Co. Dublin. The lands are generally bound by the R107 road to the east, 'Beech Lodge' to the south, Clairville Lodge to the south (off Carey's Lane), by dwellings known as 'The Coop', 'Halstead' and 'Rockport House' to the south west (off Carey's Lane) and Abington to the west AI Received 03/02/2023