3893/19: Refused planning record / PlanIntel

Decision details

Core application dates and identifiers from the public planning record.

Application ref: 3893/19
Received: 30 August 2019
Decided: 17 October 2019
FI requested: No

Authority: Dublin City Council
Application type: Permission
Outcome: Refuse permission
Source status: Documents indexed. Reason extraction for Dublin City has not started yet.

Planning analysis

Refusal reasons and planning conditions extracted from the public decision file.

Refusal reasons

Refusal reasons not machine-readable

Documents are indexed. Reason extraction for Dublin City has not started yet.

Conditions

No conditions

No conditions are on record for this application yet.

Source documents

Original council portal records and source PDFs where available.

Source link pending

This application was published at source, but the document inventory has not been bound yet.

Nearby precedent

Similar nearby applications linked to this planning decision.

WEB1740/23RETENTION: The development consists of: 1. A 2m high timber fence severing the existing garage from 23 Shanowen Avenue to serve 23A Shanowen Avenue, 2. The change of use of part of the existing single-storey garage at 23 Shanowen Avenue as ancillary family accommodation of 28 sqm to the existing house at 23A Shanowen Avenue and 3. A pedestrian gate constructed at the northern boundary wall to Shanowen Road. / 0.0 km away / 27 October 2023Refused
WEB2012/25RETENTION: The development consists of: Retention of (1) tarmac finish to front driveway, (2) altered barbecue structure to rear garden, (chimney removed, pipe flue used), (3) 4.02m vehicle entrance width. / 0.1 km away / 25 June 2025Refused
3233/24RETENTION: Retention permission sought to retain existing granny flat to rear, together with planning permission for covered link walkway and single storey kitchen extension all at rear of 190 Shanowen Road. / 0.1 km away / 12 April 2024Refused
3328/20Permission for part demolition of existing garage, to replace and extend to provide a one-bedroom mews to the rear. / 0.2 km away / 30 October 2020Refused
3923/20Planning permission to install 9 no. 2m high antenna, 9 no. 0.8m antenna and 6 no. 0.6m transmission dishes on ballast mounted supporting poles together with equipment cabinets, cabling and associated site works at the roof level. / 0.2 km away / 16 February 2021Refused
2891/19Planning permission for revisions to a previously permitted development at Blocks B and C, Milner's Square (the site of the former engineering works), Shanowen Road, Santry, Dublin 9. The site is bounded to the north by Shanowen Road, to the east by the existing Milner's Square residential development (Blocks E and F) and to the west by Shanowen Business Park. The proposed development will consist of amendments to previously permitted residential development, granted under Reg. Ref. 6058/04; ABP Ref. PL29N.211692 (as extended by Reg. Ref. 6058/04/X1, 6058/04/X2 and 6058/04/X3) and as previously revised by Reg. Ref. 4128/18, Reg. Ref. 4360/17 and 4608/17. The proposed revisions relate to previously permitted Blocks B and C (currently under construction) and will comprise of the following: (1) Block B - Modifications to the previously permitted fourth floor of Block B and the provision of a new fifth, sixth and seventh floor to now comprise an 8-storey apartment block (7 storeys with set back penthouse level) over basement level car park, comprising a total of 65 no. residential units (46 no. previously permitted under Reg. Ref. 4128/18) consisting of 22 no. 1-bedroom units, 40 no. 2-bedroom units and 3 no. 3-bedroom units with balconies/terraces to all elevations; (2) Block C - Modifications to the previously permitted Block C including a new fifth and sixth floor to now comprise a 7-storey apartment block over basement level car park, comprising a total of 53 no. residential units (31 no. previously permitted under Reg. Ref. 4608/17) consisting of 16 no. 1-bedroom units and 37 no. 2-bedrom units with balconies/terraces to all elevations. The proposed amendments will provide a total of 118 no. apartments within Blocks B and C (77 no. units previously permitted) and a total of 188 no. apartments within Phase 2 of the Milner's Square development; (3) The proposed development will also consist of all associated internal and external modifications to the previously permitted blocks to facilitate this development; and all associated engineering and site development works necessary to facilitate the development. / 0.3 km away / 25 June 2019Refused
2039/20Planning Permission for revisions to Blocks B and C of Phase 2 only (which are currently under construction) of the previously permitted development at Milner's Square (the site of the former engineering works), Shanowen Road, Santry, Dublin 9. The site is generally bounded to the north by Shanowen Road and to the east by the existing Milner's Square residential development (Blocks E and F) and to the west by Shanowen Business Park. The development was previously permitted under Reg. Ref. 6058/04; ABP Ref. PL29N.211692 (as extended by Reg. Ref. 6058/04/X1, 6058/04/X2 and 6058/04/X3) and as previously revised by Reg. Ref. 4128/18, Reg. Ref. 4360/17 and 4608/17. The proposed revisions will consist of the following: (i) Alterations to Block B comprising the subdivision of the previously permitted Management Suite to provide 1 no. residential hub (ancillary to the residential units) and a smaller management suite at ground floor level; (ii) to omit the previously approved 4 no. 3-bedroom apartment units at fourth floor level and replace with 6 no. 2 bedroom duplex apartment units and 2 no. 3-bedroom duplex apartment units over fourth floor and a proposed new fifth floor level with balconies to the east, west and north elevations (4 units will be omitted and replaced with 8 units, a net increase of 4). Please note that previously permitted units (numbers 49 and 50 on current proposal located to the southern end the 4th floor) of Block B are being retained. The proposed amendments to Block B will provide a total of 50 no. residential units with a 6 storey Block B (46 no. units previously permitted; (iii) associated changes to the elevations to Block B; (iv) changes to previously approved balcony finished from metal railing to glazed balustrade with metal railings throughout Block B; (v) associated internal alterations to facilitate the amendments; (vi) alterations to Block C to omit 8 no. 2 bedroom duplex units at ground and first floors; 2 no. 2 bedroom apartments at ground floor level and 2 no. 2 bedroom apartments at first floor level (12 no. units in total omitted) and replace with 8 no. 1 bedroom apartments at ground floor; 2 no. 2 bedroom apartments at ground floor level (all with terraces to the southern elevation) and 4 no. 1 bedroom apartments and 4 no. 2 bedroom apartments at first floor level all with balconies to the southern elevation (12 units will be omitted and replaced with 18 units, a net increase of 6 between ground and first floors); (vii) omit 4 no. 3-bedroom apartments and 1 no. 2-bedroom apartment at fourth floor (5 units in total will be omitted) and replace with 9 no. 2-bedroom duplex apartment units and 1 no. 1-bedroom duplex apartment unit at fourth floor and proposed new fifth floor level, with balconies to the south, east and north elevations (5 units will be omitted and replaced with 10 units, a net increase of 5). The proposed amendments to Block C will provide a total of 42 no. residential units within a 6 storey Block (31 no. units previously permitted; (viii) associated changes to the elevations to Block C including revisions to previously permitted corner windows at 2nd, 3rd and 4th floors; (ix) changes to previously approved balcony finishes from metal railing to glazed balustrade with metal railings throughout Block C; (x) associated internal alterations to facilitate the proposed amendments; (xi) revised landscaping proposals including a green wall to the east elevation of Block A (green wall on southern elevation of Block B is provided asper condition 5; (iii) provision of 2 no. children's play area extending to 169m2 and 227m2 in the communal open space area; (xiv) revisions to the basement layout to provide additional bicycle parking spaces (190 no. bicycle spaces now proposed; (xv) reduction in number of car parking spaces from 163 spaces to 156 spaces; (xvi) provision of 40 no. secure storage units in the basement; (xvii) all associated engineering and site development works necessary to facilitate the development. / 0.3 km away / 06 March 2020Refused
4066/19Planning permission for revisions to Phase 2 only (Blocks A,B,C & D which are currently under construction) of the previously permitted development at Milner’s Square (the site of the former engineering works), Shanowen Road, Santry, Dublin 9. The site is generally bounded to the north by Shanowen Road and to the east by the existing Milner’s Square residential development (Block E and F) and to the west by Shanowen Business Park. The development was previously permitted under Reg. Ref.6058/04; ABP Ref. PL29N.211692 (as extended by Reg. Ref. 6058/04/X1, 6058/04/X2 and 6058/04/X3) and as previously revised by Reg. Ref. 4128/18, Reg. Ref. 4360/17 and 4608/17. The proposed revisions will consist of the following: (i) alterations to Block C to remove the 8 no. 2 bedroom duplex units at ground and first floors and the 2 no. 2 bedroom apartments at ground floor level and 2 no. 2 bedroom apartments at first floor level (12 no. units in total) and to provide 8 no. 1 bedroom apartments and 2 no. 2 bedroom apartments at ground floor level with terraces to the southern elevation and to the southern elevation and 4 no. 1 bedroom apartments and 4 no. 2 bedroom apartments at first floor level with balconies to the southern elevation (18 no. units proposed in total); The proposed amendments will provide a total of 37 no. residential units within Block C (31 no. units previously permitted; (ii) revisions to previously permitted corner windows; (iii) changes in finish of balcony treatment from previously approved metal railing to glazed balustrade with metal railing throughout; (iv) associated internal alterations and elevational changes to facilitate the amendments; (v) revised landscaping proposals including a green wall to east elevation of Block A; (vi) and all associated engineering and site development works necessary to facilitate the development. / 0.3 km away / 18 November 2019Refused

3893/19: Planning permission sought for provision of retailers off-licence (5sqm), subsidiary to the main retail use at Spar, Block A1, Shanowen Square, Shanowen Road, Santry, Dublin 9, D09 A3P8.

Site

What is on file