PL06S.231377Submitted 16 October 2008 / decided 16 March 2009
Appeal decidedRefuse Permission
- Appeal submittedAppeal reference PL06S.23137716 October 2008
- Appeal decisionRefuse Permission16 March 2009
Woodtown Manor, Stocking Lane, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16
Planning application SD08A/0549
DecisionRefuse permission
Decided19 September 2008
Application typePermission
Source documents1
Site
What is on file
0refusal reasons0conditions8nearby records
Proposed development
Application description published by South Dublin County Council.Application and appeal history
Structured appeal stages, outcomes and source documents currently tied to this application.Decision details
Core application dates and identifiers from the public planning record.Planning analysis
Refusal reasons and planning conditions extracted from the public decision file.Refusal reasons
Refusal reasons not machine-readable
Documents are indexed. Reason extraction for South Dublin has not started yet.
Conditions
No conditions
No conditions are on record for this application yet.
Planning a project near Woodtown Manor, Stocking Lane, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16?
Get a site risk brief with the local decision pattern and up to 80 detailed nearby comparables (40 refusals and 40 grants), including extracted reasons and source links. €39 incl. VAT, PDF by email.Searching the records is free. A one-off brief for this site is €39, and Pro at €19/month adds full document access and the planning AI for people tracking more than one site.Source documents
Original council portal records and source PDFs where available.Included in site brief
1 council document — in the €39 site risk brief
Site brief
Nearby precedent
Similar nearby applications linked to this planning decision.- SD02A/0697/EPHotel development. The development was to comprise of 120 bedrooms over three storeys, including conference, leisure, ancillary hotel facilities and associated car parking. Permission is also sought for a change of use of Woodtown Manor (a Protected Structure) from residential to hotel use including the conversion of the stable buildings to hotel apartment use (6 no. suites) and the demolition of single storey semi derelict outbuildings. The application also included permission for a temporary waste water treatment plant. A request for further information required a number of issues to be addressed which alters the design of the scheme, which now has a revised site layout. The revised proposal provides for: the partial removal of a 3 storey block, involving the removal of 22 no. bedrooms; the retention of single semi-derelict outbuildings and the subsequent movement of the surrounding development 14 metres approximately, from the protected structure in a south east direction; the reconfiguration of the car parking layout including the movement of 116 no. spaces to the rear (east) of the hotel; the reduction of the number of car parking from 350 to 328. / 0.1 km away / 10 March 2009Refused
- SD07A/1035/EPConstruction of 394 no. residential units with a total gross floor area (GFA) of 52.632sq.m.in a mix of 1 to 4 storey buildings (Blocks comprising Unit Types K, L and Y being 3/4 storey(4 storey overall) over single storey basement car park level), comprising 196 no. houses with total GFA of c.31.267sq.m. comprising 2 no. 3 bed detached houses at c.129sq.m. GPA; 9 no. 4 bed detached houses at c.146sq.m. GFA; 19 no. 5 bed detached houses ranging in size from c. 209sq.m. to 253sq.m. GPA; 45 no. 3 bed semi-detached houses ranging in size from c.123sq.m. to c.170sq.m. GFA; 55 no. 4 bed semi-detached houses ranging in size from c.136sq.m.to c.203sq.m. GPA; 16 no. 5 bed semi-detached houses at c.175sq.m. GFA; 11 no. 2 bed terraced houses ranging in size from c.102sq.m. to c.123sq.m. GFA; 27 no. 3 bed terraced houses ranging in size from c.123sq.m. to c.170sq.m. GFA; 12 no. 4 bed terraced houses ranging in size from c.172dq.m. to c.205sq.m. GFA. Dormer windows are provided on Unit Types A, A1, A2, D, D2, F, F1, H. Balconies/terraces are provided on House Types A, B2, D2, F, H; 198 no. apartment, duplex and triplex units with total GFA at c.21,365sq.m.comprising 41 no. 2 bed apartments ranging in size from c.78sq.m. to 93sq.m.; 6 no. 3 bed apartment units at c.121sq.m.; 99 no. 2 bed duplex apartments ranging in size from c.85sq.m.to 115sq.m. GFA; 11 no. 3 bed duplex apartments ranging in size from c.115sq.m. to c.151sq.m. GFA; 26 no. 4 bed duplex apartments ranging in size from c.149sq.m. to 162sq.m.GFA; 5 no. 2 bed triplex apartment at c.158sq.m. GFA; 10 no. 3 bed triplex apartments ranging in size from c.115sq.m. to c.150sq.m. GFA; balconies/terraces are provided on all apartment, duplex and triplex units. Provision of 1 no. 2 storey building comprising 1 no. creche at ground floor level (GFA c200sq.m.) and 1 no. community facility at 1st floor level(GFA c.145sq.m.). The scheme provides for a total of 642 no. car parking spaces - 104 at basement level of blocks K, L and Y; and 538 no. within driveways/garages/on-street. Basement of Blocks comprising Units K, L and Y also provide bicycle parking, storage and bin storage facilities. The total GFA of the proposed development is c.52,977sq.m. plus additional c.3,804sq.m. at basement level Blocks comprising Unit Types K, L and Y. Vehicular access to the application site is via 3 no. access roads through adjoining lands to the north of the application site, which link to Stocking Avenue (east-west Distributor Road) as follows: 2 no. access roads via permitted residential development, Stocking Wood (SD04A/0393, under construction); and 1 no. access via permitted access road (Reg. Ref. SD06A/0046) from a roundabout on the east-west Distributor Road ( Stocking Avenue); all ancillary site development, landscaping and boundary treatment works. All on a site bounded to the west and north-west by residential development under construction permitted under Reg. Ref. SD06A/0238; to the north by an access road from east-west Distributor Road(Stocking Avenue) (permitted under Reg. Ref. SD06A/0046); by undeveloped agricultural lands and by Stocking Wood residential estate (partially constructed, permitted under Reg. Ref. SD04A/0393); and to the east and south by agricultural lands. All of which are to the south of the Stocking Avenue (east-west Distributor Road). / 0.3 km away / 11 October 2013Refused
- SD06A/0611The development will consist of: the construction of 396 no. residential units in a mix of 2/3/4 storey buildings with a total gross floor area (GFA) of c.55,095 sqm comprising 245 no. houses with total GFA of c.39,304 sqm comprising 40 no. 5 bed units: 123 no. 4 bed units (59 no. with garages); 82 no. 3 bed units: dormer windows are provided on Unit Types A, A1, A2, D, D1, D2, F, F1, H: balconies / terraces are provided on House Types A2, B2, D2, F, H; 151 no.apartment / duplex units with total GFA of c. 15,791 sqm comprising 44 no. 4 bed duplex units; 37 no. 3 bed units; and 70 no. 2 bed units: balconies / terraces are provided on Unit Types M, N,M1,N1,O, P,Q,R,T, U, V, W, X; provision of 1 no. 2 storey building comprising 1 no creche at ground floor level (GFA c.200sqm) and 1 no. community facility at 1st floor level (GFA c.145 sqm); the total GFA of the proposed development is c.55,440 sqm: vehicular access to the application site is via 3 no. access roads through adjoining lands to the north of the application site which link to the East - West Distributor Road as follows: 2 no. access roads via permitted residential development (SD04A/0393, under construction ) and 1 no. access via a proposed access road from roundabout on East - West Distributor Road ( subject to a current planning application SD06A/0046); all ancillary site development, landscaping and boundary treatments works on site bounded to the north by residential development under construction (SD04A/0393) and undeveloped agricultural lands, all of which are to the south of the East - West Distributor Road; to the east and south by agricultural lands; and to the west and north-west by undeveloped lands ( subject to current planning applications SD06A/0238 and SD06A/0046). / 0.3 km away / 08 September 2006Refused
- SD07A/0408Detached bungalow and sewage treatment facility on site at side of existing cottage, together with replacement of existing septic tank with new sewage treatment facility for the existing cottage, and associated siteworks including shared entrance. / 0.3 km away / 26 July 2007Refused
- SD05A/0935Dormer type house with a biocycle water treatment plant and shared vehicular access in side garden of existing dwelling. / 0.3 km away / 20 January 2006Refused
- SD18A/0204Permission and outline permission for development, respectively, for a mixed use scheme on two sites identified as Site A and Site B, respectively, with a combined area c. 10.14 hectares. The proposed development on Site A, for which permission development is sought, will consist of the construction of a residential scheme comprising: 65 residential units (8,310sq.m) comprising: 51 houses (31 4-bed houses (1 detached unit; 2 semi-detached units; 12 end terrace units and 16 mid terrace units) and 20 3-bed houses (2 detached units; 16 semi-detached units and 2 mid terrace units) and 14 apartments (6 single storey apartments (4 1-bed units and 2 2-bed units) and 8 3-bed duplex apartments). The development of Site A will also consist of the provision of 121 car parking spaces; bicycle parking; internal access roads; public and private open space (including areas of hard and soft landscaping); PV solar panels on roofs; waste storage facilities; Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SUDS); boundary treatment works; signage; lighting; 1 ESB substation; changes in level; site services (foul and surface water drainage and water supply); and all other associated site excavation, infrastructural and site development works above and below ground. The proposed development on Site B for which outline permission for development is sought, will consist of the construction of an educational campus (comprising a two storey 16 classroom primary school (2,407sq.m); a two storey 37 classroom post primary school (10,095sq.m) and playing pitch (c. 2.67 ha). The development of Site B will also consist of the provision of 114 car parking spaces; 660 bicycle parking stands; areas of hard and soft landscaping; extension of the footpath along Ballycullen Road; waste storage facilities; Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SUDS); boundary treatment works; lighting; changes in level; site services (foul and surface water drainage and water supply); and all other associated site excavation, infrastructural and site development works above and below ground. Site A (c. 1.9 ha) is located south of Stocking Avenue (west of Stocking Wood Copse), Ballycullen Dublin 16; Site B (c.8.24 ha) is located east of Ballycullen Road (south of Abbot's Grove), Oldcourt, Dublin 16. (Two Protected Structures are located in Site B: a Stone Cross, RPS Ref. 360 and St. Columcille's Well (Holy Well) RPS Ref. 362. For the avoidance of any doubt, no works are proposed to the protected structures). The development proposed requires the 'relocation' of the specific objective (Objective PS (Proposed Primary School) to provide a primary school set out in South Dublin County Council Development Plan 2016-2022 (as shown on map 10) from Site A to Site B. / 0.4 km away / 24 July 2018Refused
- S01A/0727Dormer bungalow. / 0.4 km away / 08 October 2002Refused
- SD09A/0206Split level dwelling with mezzanine bedroom and bathroom, within the curtilage of Woodtown Park (a Protected Structure), associated drainage works incorporating Bioflow effluent treatment plant and percolation area. / 0.4 km away / 04 February 2010Refused